Europe debates negotiations with Russia: Kallas insists on tough stance

European countries have not yet reached an agreement on a common position regarding possible negotiations with Russia to end the war in Ukraine. Some governments are proposing gradual steps to resume dialogue with Moscow. The EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs, Kaja Kallas, insists that Russia must make concessions even before full-fledged negotiations begin.
According to Censor.NET, Politico reports on this.
After agreeing on the composition of the European negotiating team, the allies faced a more difficult task: determining the common terms for dialogue with Russia, the principles of the negotiations, and the red lines that the delegation would not be allowed to cross.
According to Politico, differences emerged during the drafting of a 15-point document ahead of the foreign ministers' meeting.
Austria proposed focusing on measures to build trust between the parties. Specifically, this involves a limited or partial cease-fire as a first step toward a broader truce, as well as the creation of an international forum to monitor compliance with a potential peace agreement.
Norway, which is not part of the EU negotiating team, is also maintaining contact with Moscow. The country’s Foreign Minister, Espen Bart Eide, believes that Europeans should determine in advance which issues they will not discuss with the Russian side.
He also suggests drawing on the lessons of the Cold War, particularly the 1975 Helsinki Final Act and arms control agreements.
Callas is demanding that Russia make concessions first
There are some disagreements regarding the powers of the European negotiators. Some countries are in favor of a flexible mandate that would allow the delegation to respond independently to Russia’s proposals and seek compromises.
According to Politico, one option under discussion is for the document to be drafted by EU ambassadors rather than foreign ministers. At the same time, such a mandate could extend to representatives of European institutions and advisers from France, Germany, Italy, and Poland, but would not include representatives from the United Kingdom or NATO.
Callas insists that the negotiating mandate should be shaped specifically by the heads of foreign affairs ministries. She also believes that Europe should begin the dialogue by setting the highest possible demands on Russia, rather than weakening its own position from the outset.
The diplomat explains this principle as follows: first, the parties should put forward their maximum demands, and only then determine where compromises are possible. The final limits of concessions should not be revealed at the beginning of negotiations.
During a meeting of European leaders in Dublin on November 13, Callas stated:
"If one side starts out with the most demanding terms and the other side asks for nothing, it's easy to guess how such negotiations will end."
The Baltic states do not want to make concessions on security issues
Lithuanian Foreign Minister Kęstutis Budrys has taken a particularly clear stance on the negotiations. He called on European countries to speak with one voice and stressed that Russia should not be granted a veto over Ukraine’s accession to the EU, NATO’s presence, or the Alliance’s collective defense arrangements.
"The eastern flank is not up for negotiation. There can be no spheres of influence or new Yalta Agreements," Budris said on November 16.
Ministers from the Baltic states, Northern Europe, and NATO’s eastern flank are taking a similar approach. They support the sequence of steps that Kallas is insisting on: first, Russia must cease fire; then a peace agreement can be discussed; and only after that can security guarantees for Ukraine and the region be addressed.
Estonian Foreign Minister Margus Tsahkna also urged that a ceasefire not be replaced by discussions about the future structure of Europe. According to him, it is Vladimir Putin who must be the first to declare a ceasefire.
What actions is the EU demanding that Russia take?
On November 16, Callas outlined the European Union's demands on Moscow. Among them were:
-
respect for the sovereignty, independence, and territorial integrity of Ukraine;
-
refusal to legally recognize the occupied Ukrainian territories;
-
Russia's responsibility for war crimes and compensation for the damage caused;
-
the return of deported Ukrainian children;
-
an end to Russian sabotage and cyberattacks in Europe.
Callas also pointed out that the principles of European security are already enshrined in international documents, notably the Helsinki Final Act and the Budapest Memorandum. In her view, the problem lies not in the absence of rules, but in the fact that Russia is violating them.
The diplomat warns that discussing Russia's proposals to reshape Europe's security architecture before a ceasefire is reached could divert attention from the main issue—ending Russian aggression.
Putin invited Europeans to come to Moscow
Amid discussions in Europe, Putin stated on November 19 that Moscow had invited European representatives to visit Russia to present its position on the upcoming negotiations.
According to the Russian leader, the proposal was conveyed through diplomatic channels. Following the meeting with European representatives, the Kremlin will reportedly determine the format in which to continue the dialogue on Ukraine.
Putin also claimed that the U.S. is insisting on European participation in the negotiation process. At the same time, no agreement regarding a visit by a European delegation to Moscow has been announced yet.
According to Politico, European negotiators expect talks to resume in Abu Dhabi in the coming weeks. Two EU officials told the publication that European representatives plan to participate in the next round of talks with the Russian side, despite Russia’s ongoing attacks on Ukraine.