ENG
11870 visitors online
The Supreme Court of Ukraine has recently resolved numerous pivotal cases impacting the legal landscape. Notably, it clarified when proceedings involving servicemembers must be suspended. Amid martial law, the Court affirmed that all citizens, regardless of religious beliefs, must fulfill military duties. Furthermore, the Court upheld the conviction of Yurii Hrymchak, former Deputy Minister for TOT, highlighting a firm stance on anti-corruption. Another significant ruling stated that disobedience during military service constitutes a crime, irrespective of serious consequences. Additionally, media reports reveal concerns about judges' personal assets and dual citizenship issues. These developments showcase ongoing judicial reforms and challenges in judicial integrity in Ukraine.
How does the Supreme Court influence servicemember cases?
The Supreme Court has specified circumstances under which courts must suspend or proceed with cases involving servicemembers. This ensures fair treatment while considering service obligations. Such clarity aids in balancing legal processes with national defense priorities, especially during martial law.
Are religious beliefs considered for exemption from military service?
Under current Supreme Court rulings, religious beliefs alone do not exempt Ukrainian citizens from military duties. During martial law, every citizen is required to serve. This decision reinforces the principle of equal duty to national service, ensuring that all citizens participate in the country's defense.
What was the Supreme Court's decision regarding Yurii Hrymchak?
The Supreme Court upheld a 10-year imprisonment sentence for Yurii Hrymchak, former Deputy Minister for TOT. This confirms previous rulings from the High Anti-Corruption Court. The decision underscores the judiciary's commitment to combating corruption and maintaining the rule of law in public office.
What legal obligations do servicemen have under the Supreme Court's guidance?
The Supreme Court determined that disobedience by servicemen, regardless of the absence of serious consequences, is a crime. This means servicemen must follow orders, highlighting the importance of discipline and adherence to military protocols. The ruling is a key precedent in maintaining order and accountability in the armed forces.
Are there concerns about judicial integrity in Ukraine's Supreme Court?
Yes, recent reports expose concerns about judicial integrity, including issues of undeclared assets and dual citizenship among judges. These revelations raise questions about transparency and the ethical standards within the judiciary. Ongoing judicial reforms aim to address such challenges and restore public trust in the legal system.
What was the impact of the Supreme Court's decision on judicial reform?
The Supreme Court's decisions continue to impact judicial reform efforts. By defining roles and upholding strict conduct standards, the Court plays a pivotal role in shaping an independent and accountable judiciary. Such actions are crucial for Ukraine's alignment with European legal standards and its broader reform agendas.
How does the Supreme Court handle appeals related to moblization violations?
In cases of mobilization violations, the Supreme Court determined that unlawfulness in conscription does not absolve individuals from military service. This ruling reinforces accountability and ensures that defense duties are upheld, despite procedural challenges. It upholds the integrity of the mobilization process during national emergencies.
News SCU
Supreme Court denied Poroshenko’s request to lift sanctions imposed against him The Administrative Court of Cassation, a division of the Supreme Court, denied fifth president Petro Poroshenko’s request to overturn the sanctions imposed against him by the National Security and Defense Council. 6 666 124 Previously in trend: Sanctions against Poroshenko
Supreme Court upholds legality of confiscating UAH 1.8 million from Zhuk, head of division at Department for Combating Drug-Related Crime The Cassation Civil Court within the Supreme Court has upheld the legality of HACC decisions to recover into state revenue UAH 1.8 million, the value of a share in an apartment that belonged to Yevhen Zhuk, head of a division of the Department for Combating Drug-Related Crime of the National... 925 8 Previously in trend: Confiscation of unjustified assets
HACC sets UAH 3 million bail for Supreme Court judge Yelenina in corruption case The High Anti-Corruption Court imposed a preventive measure on Supreme Court judge Zhanna Yelenina in the form of bail set at UAH 3 million as part of an investigation into a corruption case linked to the Supreme Court. 958 2 Previously in trend: Corruption in the Supreme Court
UAH 2.5 million and UAH 2 million: HACC imposes preventive measures on Supreme Court judges in corruption case The High Anti-Corruption Court has imposed preventive measures on two judges of the Supreme Court of Ukraine who are suspected of involvement in a corruption case. 1 181 10 Previously in trend: Case of Supreme Court judge Kniaziev Corruption in the Supreme Court
Four more judges served notices of suspicion in Supreme Court corruption case – SAPO SAPO and NABU served new notices of suspicion to three sitting Supreme Court judges and a retired judge in a case involving a bribe for a ruling in favor of the owner of the "Finance and Credit" group. 2 788 15 Previously in trend: Fighting corruption in Ukraine Corruption in the Supreme Court
Corruption in Supreme Court: NABU and SAPO conduct investigative actions, including at Kniaziev’s premises. PHOTOS Anti-corruption bodies are conducting investigative actions as part of a corruption case involving the Supreme Court. 6 684 17 Previously in trend: Results of NABU and SAPO operations
Judge Hryhorieva, in whose possession NABU found $50,000 during search in Kniazev case, may cancel search of Tymoshenko’s premises, - AntAC Supreme Court judges Iryna Hryhorieva, Oleksandr Marchuk and Viacheslav Nastavnyi have opened proceedings in response to Yulia Tymoshenko’s appeal against the High Anti-Corruption Court’s ruling authorising urgent searches of the MP’s premises. 5 450 18 Previously in trend: Tymoshenko’s Case
Supreme Court has specified cases when courts must suspend proceedings in cases involving servicemembers The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court has outlined when courts are required to suspend proceedings and when they must continue hearings in cases involving servicemembers. 3 190 11 Previously in trend: Supreme Court rulings on servicemembers
Under martial law, religious beliefs do not exempt citizens from military service – Supreme Court During the period of martial law, all Ukrainian citizens — including Jehovah’s Witnesses — are required to fulfill their military duty and serve in the armed forces. 7 493 105 Previously in trend: mobilization Mobilization deferral
Supreme Court upheld sentence of former Deputy Minister for TOT Hrymchak: 10 years of imprisonment The Criminal Cassation Court of the Supreme Court upheld the verdict of the High Anti-Corruption Court (HACC) and the ruling of the HACC Appeals Chamber, which sentenced former Deputy Minister for Temporarily Occupied Territories (TOT) Yurii Hrymchak to 10 years of imprisonment. 4 520 14 Previously in trend: Hrymchak detained
Fact of violation of requirements of TCR during mobilization does not exempt person liable for military service from conscription – Supreme Court The procedure for calling up a citizen liable for military service during mobilization is irreversible, and the recognition of the conscription procedure as unlawful does not entail the dismissal of an illegally mobilized person from military service. 6 238 69 Previously in trend: Conflict with TCR Unlawful actions of the TCR
Supreme Court Judge Zhukov lives in $1m estate near Kyiv with vineyards and lakes: all registered to old friends - media. VIDEO+PHOTOS The family of Supreme Court of Cassation judge Serhii Zhukov lives in a 4-hectare estate near Kyiv, where, in addition to houses, there are also lakes and vineyards. Nothing is registered there for Zhukov himself - it all officially belongs to people close to him. 16 086 110
Supreme Court judge Stetsenko has Russian passport - sources. DOCUMENT Judge of the Administrative Court of Cassation within the Supreme Court Semen Stetsenko has Russian citizenship. 4 725 19
There is tendency to increase number of cases of AWOL - Supreme Court Chief Justice Kravchenko Chief Justice of the Supreme Court Stanislav Kravchenko notes a tendency to increase the number of registered cases of AWOL, desertion and failure to comply with orders. 16 695 192 Previously in trend: War
Supreme Court Judge Dashutin has no real estate: mother-in-law’s cottage, mother’s apartment and leased car - media. VIDEO Ihor Dashutin is a judge of the Administrative Court of Cassation of the Supreme Court of Ukraine. He has held this position since 2019. Before that, he was a judge in Sumy. Dashutin and his wife Anna do not own any real estate or cars. They use only what belongs to their relatives. 7 290 57 Previously in trend: Fighting corruption in Ukraine
Supreme Court has made decision that actually allows almost 180 dishonest judges to remain in their positions - AntAC On 13 June, the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court issued a decision that could have a significant impact on the implementation of judicial reform and the lustration of courts. In this case, a judge challenged the procedure of qualification assessment of judges. 4 572 31
Disobedience of serviceman is considered crime even in absence of serious consequences - Supreme Court The Supreme Court ruled that disobedience of a military officer is a crime with formal elements, so criminal liability for it does not depend on the occurrence of socially dangerous consequences. 24 226 134
Supreme Court clarified conditions under which it is possible to refuse mobilization due to religious beliefs The Supreme Court named the criteria that a person liable for military service must meet in order to be able to refuse mobilisation on the grounds of religious belief. 18 883 93
Offered to give occupiers South of Ukraine: SSU detains Supreme Court official. VIDEO&PHOTOS The SSU detained the head of one of the structural units of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, who denied Russian aggression against Ukraine. 16 263 79
Kravchenko was elected as new head of Supreme Court The Plenum of the Supreme Court elected a new chairman. Stanislav Kravchenko was elected. 29 786 122
Corruption in Supreme Court: chairman of court, Kniazev, and another figure were detained, no suspicions have been brought yet, - SAPO The SAPO confirmed the detention of the head of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, Vsevolod Kniazev. 8 738 59 Previously in trend: Grafters
Supreme Court overturns acquittal of ex-Berkut member who tortured Maidan protesters Following a cassation appeal filed by prosecutors from Prosecutor General’s Office, Supreme Court overturned a ruling by Kyiv Court of Appeal, which upheld first instance court’s acquittal of a former employee of Berkut special police battalion of Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine in Kharkiv region. This former law enforcement officer was accused of torturing protesters in Kyiv (part 2 of Article 127 of Criminal Code of Ukraine). 5 537 13 Previously in trend: Investigation of crimes against Maidan
SSU confirmed Russian citizenship of deputy chairman of Supreme Court of Lviv Today, Bohdan Lvov is to be dismissed from the post of chairman of the Commercial Court of Cassation as part of the Supreme Court. 15 956 78
Supreme Court is convinced that Ukraine will be on time to implement recommendations of European Commission on judicial reform by December Ukraine will have time to implement the recommendations of the European Commission related to the reform of the Constitutional Court and judicial reform by December. 1 680 11
Supreme Court Head Danyshevska Resigns Head of the Supreme Court, Valentyna Danyshevska, is resigning, and, respectively, she will not run for this position again. 12 696 47
Zelenskyi vows not to allow blocking of judicial reform in Ukraine Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyi has promised to prevent judicial reform in Ukraine from being blocked and to immediately assess and repulse any illegal actions in this matter, according to a statement published on the website of the head of state. 13 097 44
Court overturns CEC decision on recognizing Virastyuk as elected MP – OPORA At a meeting on Sunday, May 23, the Supreme Court cancelled the protocol of the Central Election Commission of Ukraine (CEC) dated May 19, 2021 on the establishment of the results of the midterm elections of Ukrainian parliamentarians in district No. 87 and the recognition of Vasyl Virastyuk as an elected deputy. 8 535 100 Previously in trend: Midterm election to the Verkhovna Rada
Tupytskyi And Kasminin Not Dismissed, Respective Zelenskyy’s Decree Null And Void – Constitutional Court’s Ex-Head Dombrovskyi Constitutional Court former head, Ivan Dombrovskyi, believes that the decree of President Volodymyr Zelenskyi on the abolition of the decree of the previous president on the appointment of Oleksandr Tupytskyi and Oleksandr Kasminin as judges of the Constitutional Court is null and void and does not entail any legal consequences. 6 574 98
Supreme Court puts on hold lawsuit to challenge Zelenskyi's decree on Tupytsky removal The Cassation Administrative Court within the Supreme Court has put on hold the lawsuit, in which the plaintiff for the second time challenged decree of the President of Ukraine dated December 29, 2020 No. 607/2020 on the removal of a judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, which temporarily suspended Head of the Constitutional Court Oleksandr Tupytsky from office, according to the court's press service. 2 373 19
Supreme Court receives claim of MP Kozak on appealing NSDC sanctions The Supreme Court of Ukraine received a lawsuit from MP of Ukraine Taras Kozak (from the Opposition Platform - For Life faction) to appeal against the decree of President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelenskyi on the enactment of the decision of the National Security and Defense Council (NSDC) regarding the application of personal sanctions against the MP. 3 409 33 Previously in trend: Medvedcul channels sanctions
Zelenskyi Suggests Rada Withdraw District Administrative Court’s Authorities To Consider Lawfulness Of Regulatory-Legal Acts Of Cabinet, Ministries And NBU, Transfer Them To Supreme Court President Volodymyr Zelenskyi has suggested that the Verkhovna Rada withdraw the authorities of the District Administrative Court of Kyiv (court’s head is Pavlo Vovk) to consider the lawfulness of the regulatory-legal acts issued by the Cabinet of Ministers, Ukrainians ministries and the National Bank of Ukraine, and transfer them to the Supreme Court as a court of the first instance. 5 870 20
Supreme Court definitively confirmed Darnitsa’s proprietary interest in stocks of the Borshchahivskiy Chemical-Pharmaceutical plant The Supreme Court of Ukraine satisfied the cassation claim filed by the pharmaceutical company Darnitsa and cancelled the decision of the North Business Court of Appeal of Kyiv of August 25,2020 on Darnitsa’s purchase of PJSC SIC Borshchahivskiy CPP stocks during the process of state privatization in 2015. 1 556 0
Court award to collect $350 mln from PrivatBank in favor of Surkis' companies appealed Minister of Justice Denys Maliuska announced the filing of an appeal against the ruling of the Pechersky District Court of Kyiv issued on September 2 by Judge Serhiy Vovk to collect about $350 million from PrivatBank in favour of the Surkis brothers' companies as part of an interim measure pending the hearing of the dispute on the fairness of attributing these deposits to the bail-in procedure. 6 150 33
The Supreme Court recognized the responsibility of Taras Barshchovsky, owner of "T.B. Fruit", as a guarantor for loans of 75 million euros The Supreme Court confirmed the debt of businessman Taras Barshchovsky as a guarantor of Delta Bank loans in the amount of 75 million euros. Having received the originals of the loan agreements, the court confirmed the decision of the arbitration court that came into force in March 2020 and cancelled the decision of the Northern Commercial Court of Appeal of Kyiv. 6 926 7
Bakhmatyuk to seek compensation following Supreme Court judgment on Financial Initiative Bank Bakhmatyuk noted that the court actually recognized the National Bank's guilt in the fall of the Financial Initiative. 1 859 6
Truba submits lawsuit on recognition illegality of his resignation as SBI director Former Director of the State Bureau of Investigations (SBI) Roman Truba has submitted a lawsuit to recognize a president's decree on his premature resignation as illegal one. 4 998 48
Supreme Court calling on Zelenskyi to veto law on activities of self-government judicial bodies The Supreme Court of Ukraine has asked Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyi to veto bill No. 1008 passed by the Ukrainian parliament at second reading, which amends some Ukrainian laws about activities of self-government judicial bodies. 2 117 24
Supreme Court refuses to reinstate Shokin as Prosecutor General The Cassation Administrative Chamber of the Supreme Court has refused to reinstate former prosecutor general, Viktor Shokin, on his position. 2 352 21
Yanukovych lawyers sabotage debate in his case through non-attendance, ask Supreme Court to change jurisdiction Defenders of Yanukovych – employees of Averlex law firm – failed to attend today's hearing of the Obolonskyi district court of Kyiv, where the judicial debate was to begin. 7 816 21 Previously in trend: Trial against Yanukovych
Ukraine’s new Supreme Court becomes operational today The new Supreme Court starts operating in Ukraine on Dec. 15. A the same time Higher Administrative Court, the Higher Economic Court, and the Higher Specialized Court for Civil and Criminal Cases shut down. 5 688 24
Cassation Economic Court judge Danishevska elected Ukraine's Supreme Court head Valentyna Danishevska, a judge of the Cassation Economic Court was elected chairwoman of the Supreme Court of Ukraine. 47 946 91
President and parliament no longer affect appointments in judicial system, - High Qualification Commission of Judges Chief Koziakov Under the most recent amendments to the Ukrainian legislation, the president and the parliament of the country have no more influence upon appointments in the judicial system. 11 598 85
Strong nominees to Supreme Court, but integrity concerns remain, - US Embassy The candidates selected through contests for the posts of Supreme Court judges should be considered by the Supreme Council of Justice. 16 088 73
List of nominees to Supreme Court of Ukraine. DOCUMENT (in Ukrainian) The High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine has published the final rating of nominees for the posts of judges of the Supreme Court of Ukraine. 28 672 89
High Qualification Commission of Judges approved rating of candidates to Supreme Court of Ukraine The High Qualification Commission of Judges has approved the rating list of 120 candidates for the posts within the Supreme Court of Ukraine. 13 931 38
Poroshenko demonstrates documents necessary for new Supreme Court operation President of Ukraine Petro Poroshenko demonstrated the package of documents necessary to launch the work of the all-new Supreme Court of Ukraine. 14 196 33
Ivaniushchenko case not dismissed, investigators and prosecution make no progress, - Supreme Court The Supreme Court of Ukraine has not reconsidered the decision in respect of Yurii Ivaniushchenko (Yura Yenakiyevskiy) and, accordingly, has not ruled to close criminal proceedings against him. 8 998 39
Ukraine’s Supreme Court ruled to dismiss all cases against Ivaniushchenko without notifying prosecutors, - Lutsenko Prosecutor General of Ukraine Yurii Lutsenko says the Supreme Court of Ukraine has ruled to dismiss all cases initiated against Yurii Ivaniushchenko aka Yura Yenakiyevskiy. 60 771 255
Page 1 of 2
more news
